A past transfer saga continues to have repercussions, with journalist Mark Guidi revealing that John McGinn’s near-miss with Celtic in 2018 still lingers in the mind of manager Brendan Rodgers. According to Guidi, Rodgers is “scarred” by the failure to sign McGinn, who instead joined Aston Villa and has since become a key player for the Midlands club.
“The good thing for Celtic is that they are in the driving seat,” said Guidi. “They have got him in the building every day. He has got a year to go. I am sure there have been early talks. It will just be between Brendan Rodgers and Dermot Desmond. If it’s going to get done, then it’s between them.”
Guidi’s comments suggest that this perceived slight has had a lasting impact on Rodgers, influencing his current approach to transfer dealings. “I have said on this programme before, I am positive there is a willingness from Brendan Rodgers to stay,” Guidi added. “He wants Dermot Desmond to give him the news he wants to hear that will make him sign a contract.”
The McGinn transfer saga serves as a reminder of the high stakes involved in the transfer market. The Scotland international’s successful career at Aston Villa has only added to the what-ifs surrounding Celtic’s failed pursuit. As Guidi notes, Rodgers’ desire for transfer backing will likely be a key factor in determining his future at Celtic.
“Go back to him, it will still be in the back of his mind,” Guidi said. “He will still be slightly scarred from what happened last summer at Celtic, the first time around, when they didn’t get two or three players they wanted, like John McGinn. He will have that in the back of his mind. Will you fully support him? That’s why it will be a conversation with Dermot Desmond.”
Guidi’s insights provide a fascinating glimpse into the complexities of transfer dealings and the lasting impact of past decisions. With Rodgers’ contract set to expire in 2026, the journalist’s comments highlight the importance of securing the manager’s trust and backing in the transfer market. Ultimately, the McGinn saga serves as a cautionary tale for Celtic, emphasizing the need for effective transfer planning and communication to retain top talent.
As the situation continues to unfold, Celtic fans will be keenly aware of the significance of transfer backing in securing Rodgers’ future. With Guidi’s comments providing context, it remains to be seen whether Rodgers will receive the assurances he needs to extend his stay at Celtic Park.
The potential contract extension would be a significant boost for Celtic, given the team’s dominance in Scottish football and the possibility of another Treble on the horizon. Rodgers’ continued presence would provide stability and continuity, allowing the club to build on its existing success. Guidi’s confidence in Rodgers’ future is rooted in the manager’s commitment to the club and his desire to continue building on the team’s success.
“I think Brendan Rodgers will stay beyond this time next year,” Guidi added. “A couple of years extension, and I think Celtic want to do business. He wants to kick on and I believe it when he says, ‘this is the happiest I have ever been’, because I think last year was very, very stressful. I think he will stay.”
