Everton FC has a passionate fanbase, and players who fail to demonstrate loyalty and dedication to the club often face severe backlash. The following five players have tarnished their reputations and ruined their legacy at Everton due to their actions, decisions, or transfers.
1. Nick Barmby: The Infamous Transfer
Nick Barmby’s decision to join Liverpool FC in 2000 was met with widespread criticism from Everton supporters. The midfielder’s transfer was seen as a betrayal, and he was subsequently cast as a villain. Although he won four trophies during his time at Anfield, his reputation was forever marred by his decision to cross the Mersey. Barmby’s transfer was particularly galling for Everton fans, given his previous contributions to the team. He had been a fan favorite at Goodison Park, and his departure was seen as a slap in the face.
Barmby’s move to Liverpool was not just a transfer; it was a cultural shift. He went from being a key player at Everton to being a bit-part actor at Anfield. Despite his success with Liverpool, Barmby’s legacy at Everton will always be defined by his decision to leave.
2. Wayne Rooney: A Tale of Two Transfers
Wayne Rooney’s departure from Everton to Manchester United in 2004 was a shocking move that damaged his reputation among Toffees fans. The young striker’s decision to celebrate a goal against Everton by kissing the Manchester United crest was perceived as a deliberate insult. However, his return to Everton in 2017 was met with open arms, and he was welcomed back by the fans. Rooney’s legacy at Everton is complex, reflecting both his incredible talent and his tumultuous relationship with the club.
Rooney’s initial departure from Everton was seen as a betrayal by many fans. He had grown up idolizing the club and had even worn a “Once a Blue, Always a Blue” t-shirt after scoring in the FA Youth Cup final. However, his decision to join Manchester United was motivated by a desire to succeed at the highest level. Despite the controversy surrounding his transfer, Rooney’s return to Everton showed that the club’s fans are willing to forgive and forget.
3. Ross Barkley: A Fallen Star
Ross Barkley was once hailed as a future star at Everton, but his form and behavior off the pitch ultimately led to his downfall. The midfielder’s transfer to Chelsea FC was seen as a departure too far, and he was labeled a “rat” by some fans. Barkley’s failure to live up to expectations and his perceived lack of commitment to the club have tarnished his legacy at Everton. Despite his talent, Barkley’s time at Goodison Park was marked by controversy and disappointment.
Barkley’s struggles with form and fitness have been well-documented. He had periods of brilliance on the pitch, but his inconsistency and lack of dedication led to criticism from fans and pundits alike. Barkley’s transfer to Chelsea was seen as a chance for him to revive his career, but it also marked the end of his time at Everton.
4. Abel Xavier: A Cardinal Sin
Abel Xavier’s decision to join Liverpool FC in 2002 was a shock to Everton fans. The defender’s transfer was seen as a betrayal, particularly given his relatively short time at the club. Xavier’s move to Anfield was not a successful one, and he ultimately failed to establish himself as a regular fixture in the Liverpool squad. His transfer was widely criticized, and Xavier’s legacy at Everton is one of disappointment and disloyalty.
Xavier’s transfer to Liverpool was a surprise to many fans. He had been a regular player for Everton, but his decision to leave was seen as a sign of disloyalty. Xavier’s time at Liverpool was marked by injuries and inconsistency, and he ultimately failed to make a lasting impact at the club.
5. Anthony Gordon: A Desire to Leave
Anthony Gordon’s desire to leave Everton has damaged his reputation among fans. The young forward’s willingness to depart the club has been perceived as a lack of commitment and loyalty. Gordon’s transfer request has tarnished his legacy at Everton, and it remains to be seen whether he can redeem himself in the eyes of the fans. Gordon’s situation highlights the challenges faced by young players at Everton, where loyalty and dedication are highly valued.
Gordon’s talent and potential are undeniable. However, his decision to leave Everton has raised questions about his commitment to the club. Gordon’s legacy at Everton will depend on his future actions and decisions, and it remains to be seen whether he can recover from the negative perception surrounding his departure.
The legacy of these five players serves as a cautionary tale for those who aspire to greatness at Everton. The club’s fans are fiercely loyal, and players who fail to demonstrate the same level of commitment risk facing severe backlash.
