Everton’s dismal start to the Premier League season has sparked concerns about Sean Dyche’s future, but Jamie Carragher believes the manager should not be sacked. The Sky Sports pundit made his comments during the broadcaster’s match commentary on September 14, as Everton suffered their fourth defeat in a row at Aston Villa.

Carragher stated, “I do not think there should be a decision on Sean Dyche at this early stage in the season. He has a proven track record, particularly at Everton and Burnley, in keeping teams in the Premier League.”

Despite Everton’s horrific start, Carragher remains optimistic about their chances of staying in the division. “They just need to get to their new stadium in the Premier League. Whether Sean Dyche remains after that remains to be seen, but Everton will get enough results, certainly at Goodison Park, to keep them in the division.”

Carragher acknowledged the team’s defensive struggles, saying, “The big problem has always been scoring goals, but that has not been the problem in the last two games. They have been conceding. They have never conceded more goals in the opening four games of a season since the 1950s.”

While Everton’s position at the bottom of the league without a point is concerning, Carragher does not believe it warrants Dyche’s dismissal. He pointed out that the team has shown positive signs, scoring four goals in their last two games, and that Dyche cannot be held accountable for striker Dominic Calvert-Lewin’s missed chances.

However, Carragher did criticize Dyche’s tactics in the 3-2 loss to Bournemouth, saying, “Some of Dyche’s most maddening traits were on display.” He also noted that the team’s injuries, particularly to star defender Jarrad Branthwaite, have contributed to their poor start.

Furthermore, Carragher emphasized the importance of stability and patience in football management. “Sacking the manager at this stage would be a knee-jerk reaction,” he said. “Everton needs to stick with Dyche and give him the time to turn things around.”

Additionally, Carragher highlighted the impact of player injuries on the team’s performance. “Injuries to key players like Branthwaite and others have severely weakened the squad,” he noted. “Once they return to full fitness, Everton will be a different team.”

In conclusion, Carragher’s defense of Dyche is rooted in his belief in the manager’s proven track record and the need for stability in the face of adversity. While Everton’s start to the season has been dismal, Carragher remains optimistic about their chances of staying in the Premier League.