Former FIFA referee Dermot Gallagher has provided his expert analysis on the contentious penalty incident during Celtic’s 3-1 victory over Hibernian at Celtic Park. The moment in question occurred in the first half when Chris Cadden appeared to handle the ball inside the area, sparking intense debate among players, coaches, and fans.
Gallagher, speaking on Sky Sports’ Ref Watch, offered his insights into the decision, acknowledging that while the ball did make contact with Cadden’s arm, the defender’s movement was deemed natural and in line with the rules of the game. “I think this is so close, he brings his arm down, it does strike him but he brings his arm down as you would expect the defender to do towards his body,” Gallagher explained.
The incident has been the subject of much discussion, with some arguing that Celtic were unfairly denied a penalty. However, Gallagher ultimately supported the match officials’ decision on the day. The controversy surrounding the call was further fueled by Brendan Rodgers’ previous comments regarding inconsistent officiating in key matches this season.
In the end, the decision did not prove decisive, as Celtic rallied to secure a convincing 3-1 win with goals from Nicolas Kuhn, Adam Idah, and Reo Hatate. The victory maintained Celtic’s unbeaten home streak against Hibernian at 22 matches. Despite the controversy, both the referee and VAR made the correct call, according to Gallagher’s expert analysis.
The debate surrounding the penalty decision highlights the fine margins that often decide the outcome of matches. In high-stakes games like the one between Celtic and Hibernian, every call can be scrutinized, and opinions often vary widely. Gallagher’s analysis provides valuable insight into the complexities of refereeing and the challenges faced by match officials.
As the season progresses, consistency in officiating will remain a crucial factor in determining the league standings. Celtic’s win over Hibernian was a significant result, and the team’s performance on the pitch was not overshadowed by the controversy surrounding the penalty incident. With Gallagher’s expert analysis providing clarity on the decision, the focus can now shift to the upcoming matches and the team’s continued pursuit of success.
The incident serves as a reminder of the importance of accurate and consistent refereeing in high-profile matches. While opinions may vary, Gallagher’s expertise provides a valuable perspective on the decision-making process. As the football community continues to discuss and debate the finer points of the game, Gallagher’s analysis offers a deeper understanding of the complexities involved.
Ultimately, Celtic’s victory over Hibernian was a testament to the team’s strength and resilience. Despite the controversy surrounding the penalty incident, the team demonstrated their ability to adapt and overcome adversity, securing a crucial win in the process. As the season unfolds, Celtic will look to build on this momentum and continue their pursuit of success.
